£20m 'Morrisons' supermarket gets go-ahead - but Cottingham traders say it signals 'death knell'

Trusted article source icon
Friday, November 23, 2012
Profile image for Hull Daily Mail

Hull Daily Mail

A £20m supermarket development in Cottingham has been given the go-ahead.

The new store earmarked for a site in Station Road is expected to create up to 250 jobs.

  1. OPPOSITION:  From left, Hazel Hill, Gillian Ainsworth, Lillian Clifton, Councillor Helen Green, Councillor Lena Slater, Bob Wilson and Gordon Slater in Station Road close to the supermarket site.    Picture: Peter Harbour

    OPPOSITION: From left, Hazel Hill, Gillian Ainsworth, Lillian Clifton, Councillor Helen Green, Councillor Lena Slater, Bob Wilson and Gordon Slater in Station Road close to the supermarket site. Picture: Peter Harbour

Morrisons is currently in talks with developers behind the project to operate the new supermarket.

The issue has divided opinion among residents and traders in the village since proposals were first unveiled more than a year ago.

Business Cards From Only £10.95 Delivered www.myprint-247.co.uk

myprint-247

View details

Print voucher

Our heavyweight cards have FREE UV silk coating, FREE next day delivery & VAT included. Choose from 1000's of pre-designed templates or upload your own artwork. Orders dispatched within 24hrs.

Terms: Visit our site for more products: Business Cards, Compliment Slips, Letterheads, Leaflets, Postcards, Posters & much more. All items are free next day delivery. www.myprint-247.co.uk

Contact: 01858 468192

Valid until: Sunday, June 30 2013

A similar divide emerged between councillors at yesterday's East Riding planning committee before an 8-3 vote in favour of approval subject to a number of legal agreements being finalised.

The application by Station Road Retail Ltd had attracted two petitions objecting to the development with a combined total of 1,567 signatures.

Another 240 individual letters opposing the plan were also submitted to the council.

Peter Duffuss, who represented residents at the committee, said the go-ahead for the scheme signalled the "death knell" for existing traders in Cottingham.

"This is akin to driving a few more nails into their coffin," he said.

Mr Duffuss, who lives in Thwaite Street, said already-congested roads in the village, struggling to cope with traffic tailbacks caused by two railway level crossings, would be made much worse by the decision.

He also pointed to the main access to the store being at the end of a cul-de-sac linked to an ordinary residential street.

He claimed this meant the scheme was quite different from other supermarket developments where new stores were invariably located next to major roads.

Councillor Lena Slater, who represents Cottingham, also spoke out against the development, although she was not on the committee.

After the vote, she said: "I am very disappointed.

"It will bring an irreversible change to the village.

"The new jobs being quoted are all very well but jobs will also be lost because of the impact on existing businesses.

"The council's own retail consultants have said it will have a significant adverse effect on the village.

"They predict 34 per cent of trade will be diverted from existing traders to this new supermarket.

"We could easily end up in a situation where the last man standing will be asked to put the lights out."

But developer Simon Dixon said the committee's vote to approve the scheme was a "positive step".

He said: "I think we have heard from a vociferous minority during the planning process.

"Our own surveys suggest the overwhelming majority of people in Cottingham are behind this and want to see this site being redeveloped.

"As well as the 250 jobs being created by the supermarket, we will also be employing contractors to build it which is another boost to the local economy."

He confirmed his company was in talks with Morrisons over the operation of the store.

"Those negotiations were dependent on us securing planning permission.

"Hopefully, we can now move forward on that basis to reach an agreement with Morrisons."

Committee chairman Councillor Phyllis Pollard said: "In our current economic climate with a finely -balanced issue like this, I look for applications that support economic growth."

0
Tweet this article
Report

Comments

  • Profile image for cowboy1962

    by cowboy1962

    Tuesday, November 27 2012, 10:20PM

    “is this cottingham or is this the twilight zone ?”

  • Profile image for cookinasuit

    by cookinasuit

    Tuesday, November 27 2012, 7:44PM

    “I am intrigued to note that the well known North Cave Councillor and chairwoman of the Planning Committee, Phyllis Pollard states "I look for applications that support economic growth" without even beginning to realise a very large percentage of products sold by retailers such as Morrisons are imported in to this country. Nor does she realise that retailers tend to pay very low wages and keep people on low hours because by doing so they do not have to pay employers National Insurance contributions. As this is the same Councillor Pollard who voted in favour of building 700 houses on land that is currently rated a Zone 3 flood risk (the highest Environment Agency rating) in Brough, I would suggest few people can take seriously anything she says. Lastly, I can see the dead hand of the Head of Planning and Regeneration behind this approval so we can reasonably surmise that, yet again, Councillor Pollard has done as she was told.”

  • Profile image for pebs76

    by pebs76

    Tuesday, November 27 2012, 9:19AM

    “I think its absolutely brilliant! The shops in Cottingham are expensive and have hardly any choice. The parking in Cottingham is ridiculous. I spend more time driving around in a circle looking for a space than I do shopping. I would love an Asda too while the planners are at it! The residents of Cottingham, like Beverley-ites, need to get a grip, move into this Century & STOP moaning about everything! It's hardly Buckingham Palace they're building on is it! - It's only Cottingham FGS!”

  • Profile image for HCAFCscarb

    by HCAFCscarb

    Monday, November 26 2012, 11:58PM

    “wait till tescos applies to build a super store on cottingham park..”

  • Profile image for bazza_12

    by bazza_12

    Monday, November 26 2012, 10:32PM

    “every little helps!”

  • Profile image for currensy

    by currensy

    Monday, November 26 2012, 8:16PM

    “The co-op was originaly formed to stop the poor and working class of britain from been ripped off by unscrupulous business owners as is going to be the case soon when the supermarkets wipe out any shred of competition. Then you will all see price rises, price fixing and all the other joyfull things that come with corporate business and shareholders. I long for the day of an NFP not for profit organisation to come into the market to wipe out all the big players.”

  • Profile image for gerry_gilbert

    by gerry_gilbert

    Monday, November 26 2012, 3:24PM

    “@qualitychap: "cottingham has to move on and modernise,a lot of the old type pubs are closing"

    That's not true. No pubs in Cott have closed AFAIK, and the Railway has been seriously renovated and revitalised by Maggie (ex-landlady of the Billy) into a fine real ale and occasional music pub. "Move on" is just a pointless Blairite term which means zip, as does "modernise" - do you think the village is stuck in some traditional timewarp, like a fly in aspic? Considering the national and local economic state, Cott's not doing badly, though there are perhaps a few too many cafes and charity shops for comfort. Morrison's will drain a lot of shoppers from Cott centre.

    Yes, the location is run-down but there are better things that could have been done with it other than building yet another supermarket, of which there are plenty in the area (co-op, Sainsbury's, Morrisons on the A164, Waitrose at Willerby, Tesco's at Inglemire).”

  • Profile image for Pete898

    by Pete898

    Sunday, November 25 2012, 10:16PM

    “Free parking at the new Morrisons and brand new parking charges to be introduced by the council for the rest of the villages shops...............err............I like it as a policy........for clearance of shops prior to allocating those premises to something as yet to be thought about!!! - nice.”

  • Profile image for qualitychap

    by qualitychap

    Friday, November 23 2012, 8:44PM

    “excellent news cottingham moving forward at long last,a new Costa coffee has also settled in nicely,it will make good use of a central rundown area next to the train station,infact it will probably increase property prices near it.
    the old empty Halifax building society,near the new costa coffee would also make an excellent modern wine,cafe bar,similar to lounge on prinny ave,because i bet the revamp of tiger,will be a cheap lick of paint and a new rovers return patterned carpet.
    cottingham has to move on and modernise,a lot of the old type pubs are closing,places like prinny ave and newland are doing well,because there cafe bars are modern,with a more european theme and experience.
    also local people banging on about traffic in cottingham,its always busy,particularly at rush hour,wake up people and look at the big picture,cottingham needs a bypass,west bulls over the rail line up to the old de la pole,i should be a consultant and be charging Mr parnaby for this advice,lol.”

  • Profile image for DesertSong

    by DesertSong

    Friday, November 23 2012, 8:30PM

    “Bad news.”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Be the first to comment

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article