Has Channel 4 got it in for Orchard Park?
A north Hull community has come out fighting amid fears yet another documentary will paint the city in a bad light.
Grimsby MP Austin Mitchell has spent a week in a high-rise council flat on Orchard Park for a Channel 4 series, provisionally titled Tower Block of Commons, which airs in February.
-

From left, Cllr Terry Geraghty, Doreen Smith, chair of the Courts Community Association, and Tony Fee, of the Courts Opportunity Project, pictured outside High Court flats
It comes after Hull was named the worst place to live in Channel 4's 2005 The Best and Worst Places to Live in the UK.
Its recent show, Benefit Busters, also focussed on the unemployed in the city.
Mr Mitchell is one of a number of MPs who swapped their homes to sample life on Britain's council estates.
Residents have questioned why he did not stay on an estate in his own constituency, and raised concerns Hull will once again be portrayed as the poor relations by the national media.
Tom Marshall, secretary of Danes Residents' Association, in Orchard Park, said: "Hull is one of the best cities in the country, but every time documentary-makers are around, they run it down.
"Austin Mitchell is not our MP and should not be interfering."
Councillor Terry Geraghty, who represents the Orchard Park and Greenwood ward, said: "I am very concerned this documentary will give a false impression of the area.
"We have lots of new projects and investment in Orchard Park - new centres and playgrounds, a very successful rugby team - but I doubt they will be featuring that.
"Mr Mitchell should have stayed in Grimsby for the documentary.
"There would have been a lot more for the cameras there."
Janet Reuben, chief executive of Visit Hull and East Yorkshire, said: "Perhaps the producers would like to visit St Stephen's or Hull Truck Theatre, or bring their cameras to the Freedom Festival and see this city and its residents at their best.
"The people of Hull are tired of the doom and gloom stories, they are ready for positivity and optimism and I wonder if the documentary producers have the courage to show the real Hull."
Mr Mitchell lives in High Court, off Hall Road, with his wife and one-time Channel 4 producer Linda McDougall.
The property was sub-let to TV company Love Productions by a tenant, against the terms of their agreement.
A spokesperson for Hull City Council said: "Love Productions chose to enter a private arrangement with a resident on Orchard Park.
"When approached by the production company, the council offered a flat but it was declined.
"Had they accepted, the flat would have been handed over in a clean and let-able condition, in line with the council policy.
"We are fully aware of the issues that the Orchard Park faces.
"This is why we are working on a way forward for the estate, which has been successful in securing £160m to transform the area.
"We hope that this comes across when the documentary is aired."
The plans include the new Orchard Centre, the proposed Northern Academy, the new children's centre and a new neighbourhood shopping centre.
Mr Mitchell told the Mail the amount of needles littered around Orchard Park was "monstrous" and described the flats as "primitive".
He criticised a broken toilet seat, dirty sofa and bug-spattered bath in his flat.
Despite this, he said: "Nothing I said would help the documentary portray Hull in a bad light.
"If they did, that would be dishonest and I would be the first to say it."
Mr Mitchell, chairman of the MPs' Council Housing Group, added: "I enjoyed it. I met some interesting people.
"The people were more interesting than the conditions, which were fairly tough.
"It is not the councils which are to blame, it is the government which has left them too short of money."
A Channel 4 spokesman said: "Channel 4 has commissioned a new documentary series that sees politicians staying on different estates and tower blocks across the country.
"The programmes will show the politicians experiencing the realities of living on estates across the country and whether their views on poverty and social exclusion are changed by it."








165 Comments
View all
by doug, portsmouth
Tuesday, February 02 2010, 1:51PM
“i watched the programme last night and thought chanell 4 done the best to make it as negative as possible! i think some refurbishment from the council and an apology from ch4 wud be good i am sure you would agree!”
by James, HULL, YORKSHIRE
Monday, February 01 2010, 6:35PM
“Ben, could you please cite the ever so reliable sources that lead you to believe that everyone in Hull is ignorant? You are blatantly a port drinking, humus eating toff, with your head so far up your own a*se its coming back out your mouth. Do us all a favour and say nothing at all if you have nothing good to say, yeah?”
by Ben, Beverley
Thursday, October 15 2009, 5:34PM
“Netty, you just prove the point that people from Hull are plainly ignorant. Could you please tell me in which dictionary you found the words "crtize" and "constituence"?”
by San Diego Tiger, Sunny SoCal
Thursday, October 15 2009, 4:43PM
“Every big city has it's bad areas. The blame for everything can be placed in many directions. Of course, no-one wants to be responsible and the government is an easy scapegoat.
The bottom line is; the people who live in these areas will always determine if it is a decent area to live. It could be a real doss hole, but if the residents treat each other with respect, it is a decent place to live. As happens with council estates, they are generally filled with low income families. The leading reason for low-income, is lack of education. That almost always stems from lack of desire to excel.
So now you have people with no money, no education, no ambition and no responsibility.
If the people of Orchard Park don't like how they are portrayed - maybe they should portray themselves in a better light???
I grew up in Hull in the 70's and have one question to ask: "Does anyone remember the time when Orchard Park was considered a decent place?"”
by Netty, Hull
Thursday, October 15 2009, 4:27PM
“I have noticed that MP Diana Johnson is extremely quite on this subject. As she is MP for North Hull she is showing just how much she cares about her constituence by keeping quite.”
by Craig, Hull
Thursday, October 15 2009, 3:05PM
“I lived on Orchard Park for 20 years yeah it as its problems but there are far worse places to live. And if u dont like Hull dont live here go move somewhere else. Hull is the best city in this country not that im biased or nowt Hull and proud.”
by Darcally, East of Eden
Thursday, October 15 2009, 3:01PM
“Thank the Great White Holy Heavenly Father in Heaven for the eloquent and incisive thoughts of Erik Bloodaxe. Long may he propound mightily in this theatre of the absurd.”
by hullcity13, theseaside
Thursday, October 15 2009, 1:58PM
“gypton in leeds..a far bigger slum then any place in hull...and so is moss side in manchester, toxteth in liverpool, st pauls in bristol, many areas in london, the whole of luton etc, etc.. i guess those who say hull is the worst place in the uk have never been anywhere.....”
by Netty, Hull
Thursday, October 15 2009, 1:24PM
“East Yorkshire White, Beverley. I have family and friends in Leeds and was there not so long ago and family took me around Leeds and the Market if you can call it that had rats the 4 leg type and family called the council to remove them by whatever means the council use. Leeds is no different to Hull and all those on here pulling Hull to bits then move somewhere better if you can find anywhere. Beverley has it's bad parts as any other place in the country. So critize Beverley. East Yorkshire White but Beverley is a tip. You critize Hull then expect Beverley to be critized.”
by S, East Riding
Thursday, October 15 2009, 1:20PM
“I agree that Grimsby is a miserable dump compared to Hull. At least the people of Hull and surrounding areas, are all very friendly and polite (especially in the town i reside in).
Its a shame some of the other cities dont take a leaf out of our area and learn to be as civilised and nice.”