'Flu jabs shortage could force us to play God'

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, October 16, 2012
Profile image for Hull Daily Mail

Hull Daily Mail

HEALTH officials in Cottingham fear patients are being put at risk by a lack of flu vaccinations.

Hallgate Surgery staff said there was a lack of vaccines due to a manufacturing problem.

  1. WORRY:   Lynne McCormick, practice manager at Hallgate Surgery in Cottingham.   Picture: Kate Woolhouse

    WORRY: Lynne McCormick, practice manager at Hallgate Surgery in Cottingham. Picture: Kate Woolhouse

  2. WORRY:   Hallgate Surgery staff say about 700 of the surgery's 2,500 patients need the flu vaccine.

    WORRY: Hallgate Surgery staff say about 700 of the surgery's 2,500 patients need the flu vaccine.

Practice manager Lynne McCormick said about 700 of the surgery's 2,500 patients need the vaccine.

She said: "I'm worried if we don't get enough, we will be left to decide who gets them.

Family Wildlife Discovery Offer

RSPB Blacktoft Sands

View details

Print voucher

Come and discover the wildlife at Blacktoft Sands nature reserve for just £6. Offer includes entry for 2 adults and up to 3 children, binocular hire and activities for children. Normal value £12.

Terms: Redeem voucher at visitor reception during opening hours, 9am to 5pm. Only, one pair of binoculars per voucher, customers will need to leave car keys as a deposit for binoculars.

Contact: 01405 800024

Valid until: Saturday, June 15 2013

"We don't want to be in that situation and we don't want to play God with people's health in that way.

"I have one for a young chap who is having chemotherapy. But other than that, we have nothing."

Vulnerable patients in the East Riding struggled to protect themselves against flu as vaccination stocks ran low in January last year. GPs are believed to have rationed the vaccines to prioritise those most at risk.

"At risk" groups include those over 65, pregnant women and people with chronic heart conditions.

After informing patients of flu clinics, Mrs McCormick said she has had to tell them the vaccine is not currently available.

She has placed a note in the surgery, stating: "Flu clinic cancelled until further notice due to manufacturing problems. Notification of revised clinic dates will be displayed in the surgery window as soon as vaccines are available. We apologise for the inconvenience."

Surgeries are responsible for ordering their own flu vaccines and manufacturers vary.

Mrs McCormick said Hallgate Surgery is on a waiting list with another manufacturer but she is not certain enough will be made available.

"Lots of companies are selling the vaccines to pharmacies and supermarkets, so the walking well can buy them," she said.

"I'm on a waiting list with another company but, even then, they can't guarantee how many we will get.

"We have a lot of residential homes and that's where the biggest risk is at the moment.

"We have sent out 1,000 letters advertising flu clinics to patients and we can't afford to send another round of letters. This has really left us in a mess."

Lynne said the health of the patients who need a flu vaccination is a concern.

She said: "We have some pretty poorly patients and I'm very concerned for them. If you have a mixture of asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, the consequences could be pretty dire."

Mrs McCormick said patients have raised concerns about the situation.

"We have taken a lot of flak but quite a lot of people are very worried," she said.

"The vaccination doesn't prevent flu but it stops it being fatal and progressing to pneumonia.

"If this situation happens, there should be a system where it's chronic disease patients first.

"It's not the first time this has happened but never to this degree.

"The worry and distress it causes the patients is the unacceptable side of this issue."

Health news for Hull and East Yorkshire

0
Tweet this article
Report

Comments

  • Profile image for Clem_

    by Clem_

    Tuesday, October 16 2012, 9:04PM

    “It makes you wonder why God, the creator, would build in a susceptibility to flu unless it was for his own perverse enjoyment at seeing you suffer.”

  • Profile image for bewildered1

    by bewildered1

    Tuesday, October 16 2012, 12:59PM

    “David_Nivea

    I have no god in my life but you often seem to play the Devils advocate.”

  • Profile image for SuperRick

    by SuperRick

    Tuesday, October 16 2012, 12:12PM

    “£6 at Asda - plenty of them”

  • Profile image for JoeLynas

    by JoeLynas

    Tuesday, October 16 2012, 11:36AM

    “Nobody going out and about in the sunshine needs to supplement VitaminD, This vit is free!”

  • Profile image for David_Nivea

    by David_Nivea

    Tuesday, October 16 2012, 11:30AM

    “How can anyone "...play God..." when there is no such thing?

    Anyway, Practice manager Lynne McCormick....said : "I'm worried if we don't get enough, we will be left to decide who gets them."

    Conversely, Ms. McCormick must be relaxed that if enough vaccines are supplied, staff won't have to decide anything.”

  • Profile image for cueball44

    by cueball44

    Tuesday, October 16 2012, 11:19AM

    “Go to ASDA they have plenty.”

  • Profile image for PeterAnlaby

    by PeterAnlaby

    Tuesday, October 16 2012, 11:06AM

    “Is this shortage of vaccine widespread, or just restricted to a few surgeries? I had my jab on Saturday morning at my surgery in Anlaby, only a few miles from this surgery in Cottingham. Patients were queueing out of the door with no indication that there was any shortage. Is there a problem with the system if some surgeries can't treat dangerously at-risk patients, and other surgeries can give the vaccine to anyone who ticks the right boxes?”

  • Profile image for rabidbadger

    by rabidbadger

    Tuesday, October 16 2012, 9:21AM

    “Don't worry Lynne, a recent literature review carried out by the Cochrane Collaboration suggests that these vaccines are ineffective:

    http://tinyurl.com/8on6age

    However, strengthening the immune system is still an option and there are many natural ways to achieve this. I have personally found that vitamin D supplements make a significant difference and these are available to all. Just ensure you get vitamin D3, rather than D2. A years supply of high quality D3 cost me just £10. I'm sure there are many other non-vaccine related things which can help, have any other readers tried something that has helped them?”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Be the first to comment

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         

        Related articles

         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article